← Back to Insights
June 7, 2023
David Burda
Consumerism Economics System Dynamics

Healthcare Savings — Lies and Punchlines

Healthcare executives always lie about why they did what they did, whether what they did is a merger, acquisition, affiliation or strategic partnership. The only correct answer is “for economic reasons.”

They made a deal to preserve revenue or profits or to increase revenue or profits. That’s it. Sorry.

One of my favorite lies told by healthcare executives is that a deal will save money, and they will pass those savings along to patients, members, consumers, customers or whomever. To my knowledge, no patient, member, consumer, customer or whomever saved money from a healthcare deal. And to my knowledge, no one has ever called healthcare executives out on it.

That is, until now. It’s at the end of a short but telling study published last month in Health Affairs.

Three researchers from DePaul University in Chicago wanted to find out how health insurance market power affected hospital prices. The researchers theorized that hospital prices would be lower in highly concentrated health insurance markets because the health insurers in those markets would use their market power to negotiate lower prices for care from the hospitals in those markets. In other words, such markets would behave the same way they would in any other industry given the same dynamics.

And to no one’s surprise, they do.

Using price data from about 1,500 hospitals for 14 “shoppable” medical services, the researchers found that the prices for those services were 14.7% lower in markets where one health insurer controlled 72% or more of the market compared with markets where the dominant health insurer controlled less than 48% of the market. How much lower varied significantly by hospital ownership status:

  • 31.9% lower for for-profit hospitals
  • 16.3% lower for public hospitals
  • 6.8% lower for not-for-profit hospitals

That suggests that for-profit hospitals mark up their prices significantly more than public and not-for-profit hospitals. Not a shocker there, either.

As for the 14 shoppable services, the most affected by insurer market power was electrocardiograms (ECG). In highly concentrated insurance markets, the price for an ECG was 67% lower. The least affected was 60-minute new patient office visits — only 1.5% lower.

But the punchline and idea for this post come at the end of the study when the researchers say: “A critical question for policymakers and consumers is whether savings obtained from lower prices are passed on in the form of lower premiums. The relationship to premiums is theoretically ambiguous.”

If health services research doesn’t work out for this trio, The Second City Theatre is only about a mile and a half away from DePaul. Hysterical.

Thanks for reading.

About the Author

David Burda

David Burda began covering healthcare in 1983 and hasn’t stopped since. Dave writes this monthly column “Burda on Healthcare,” contributes weekly blog posts, manages our weekly newsletter 4sight Friday, and hosts our weekly Roundup podcast. Dave believes that healthcare is a business like any other business, and customers — patients — are king. If you do what’s right for patients, good business results will follow.

Dave’s personnel experiences with the healthcare system both as a patient and family caregiver have shaped his point of view. It’s also been shaped by covering the industry for 40 years as a reporter and editor. He worked at Modern Healthcare for 25 years, the last 11 as editor.

Prior to Modern Healthcare, he did stints at the American Medical Record Association (now AHIMA) and the American Hospital Association. After Modern Healthcare, he wrote a monthly column for Twin Cities Business explaining healthcare trends to a business audience, and he developed and executed content marketing plans for leading healthcare corporations as the editorial director for healthcare strategies at MSP Communications.

When he’s not reading and writing about healthcare, Dave spends his time riding the trails of DuPage County, IL, on his bike, tending his vegetable garden and daydreaming about being a lobster fisherman in Maine. He lives in Wheaton, IL, with his lovely wife of 40 years and his three children, none of whom want to be journalists or lobster fishermen.

Recent Posts

Podcast: How Healthcare Revolutionaries Think With Melina Davis
Podcast: Melina Davis on Doctors Opening Up About Burnout One of the big problems in healthcare is physician… Read More
By June 20, 2024
The Most Important Phone Call a Hospital or Health System CEO Will Never Make
I never watched an episode of Undercover Boss, but I’m not always part of the mainstream. The first… Read More
By June 12, 2024
Burda on Healthcare: Will Consumer Complaint Portals Save Us From the System?
Former President Donald Trump — or as I call him on the 4sight Health Roundup podcast, Cheeto Jesus… Read More
By June 11, 2024