← Back to Insights
October 21, 2020
David Burda
Economics Policy System Dynamics

It’s Your Move: Health Insurers Counter Provider Consolidation

Hospitals, health systems, medical practices and other providers catch a lot of grief—and rightly so—for merger after merger and acquisition after acquisition that have done virtually nothing for patients other than raise medical prices and make care less affordable.

Health insurers counter provider consolidation with mergers and acquisitions of their own. But they for whatever reason catch less grief, even though their actions lead to higher out-of-pocket healthcare costs for members and make care less affordable, too. 

In the spirit of leveling the competitive playing field, I’ll use this space to give health insurers a little of the grief they deserve but often dodge.

The grief comes courtesy of a new report from the American Medical Association called Competition in Health Insurance: A Comprehensive Study of U.S. Markets. You can download the 67-page report here.   

What the AMA did was figure out the level of health insurance company market concentration in nearly 300 metropolitan statistical areas across the country. The AMA used enrollment data from four types of commercial health plans to calculate the market shares of different carriers in each MSA. The four types of plans were HMOs, PPOs, point-of-service plans and plans sold over state health insurance exchanges.

The AMA then calculated the level of market concentration by the carriers in each MSA using something called the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index, or HHI. The HHI measures market concentration on a scale of 1 to 10,000 with 10,000 being a perfect monopoly of a market held by just one company. The U.S. Justice Department and the Federal Trade Commission, which are charged with enforcing the federal antitrust laws, consider any market with a score above 2,500 to be highly concentrated. That means a handful of companies control most of a defined market.

The AMA found that 284 of the 384 MSAs in the study, or 74 percent, were highly concentrated health insurance markets in 2019. That’s up from 71 percent in 2014, according to the report.

At the state level, the 10 states with the most concentrated health insurance markets in 2019 were, in ranked order, according to the AMA, were: 

  1. Alabama
  2. Hawaii
  3. Michigan
  4. Delaware
  5. South Carolina
  6. Kentucky
  7. Alaska
  8. Louisiana
  9. Illinois
  10. North Carolina 

“These markets are ripe for the exercise of health insurer market power, which harms consumers and providers of care,” the AMA said. “Our findings should prompt federal and state antitrust authorities to vigorously examine the competitive effects of proposed merger between health insurers.”

When a health insurer controls a local market, it has monopsony power over providers, meaning it can dictate what it pays providers for care. The same insurer also has monopoly power over employers and patients, meaning it can dictate what it charges employers and patients for coverage.  It’s a lose-lose, if you’re a consumer. 

With wave after wave of provider consolidation met with wave after wave of insurer consolidation, it’s no wonder that healthcare services have become so expensive and less affordable for most Americans. Consumers supported by aggressive state and federal antitrust enforcement need more competition in both the provider and insurer markets to tilt the playing field in their favor.

Thanks for reading.

Stay home. Stay safe. Stay alive.  

About the Author

David Burda

David Burda began covering healthcare in 1983 and hasn’t stopped since. Dave writes this monthly column “Burda on Healthcare,” contributes weekly blog posts, manages our weekly newsletter 4sight Friday, and hosts our weekly Roundup podcast. Dave believes that healthcare is a business like any other business, and customers — patients — are king. If you do what’s right for patients, good business results will follow.

Dave’s personnel experiences with the healthcare system both as a patient and family caregiver have shaped his point of view. It’s also been shaped by covering the industry for 40 years as a reporter and editor. He worked at Modern Healthcare for 25 years, the last 11 as editor.

Prior to Modern Healthcare, he did stints at the American Medical Record Association (now AHIMA) and the American Hospital Association. After Modern Healthcare, he wrote a monthly column for Twin Cities Business explaining healthcare trends to a business audience, and he developed and executed content marketing plans for leading healthcare corporations as the editorial director for healthcare strategies at MSP Communications.

When he’s not reading and writing about healthcare, Dave spends his time riding the trails of DuPage County, IL, on his bike, tending his vegetable garden and daydreaming about being a lobster fisherman in Maine. He lives in Wheaton, IL, with his lovely wife of 40 years and his three children, none of whom want to be journalists or lobster fishermen.

Recent Posts

Burda on Healthcare: Always, Often, Sometimes, Rarely or Never Trust What the AMA Tells You About Prior Authorization
The American Medical Association (AMA) released the results of its latest annual survey of physicians on prior authorization… Read More
By July 23, 2024
4sight Friday 7/19/2024
4sight Friday | Two Secrets to Value-Based Care Adoption | Why Dave Terry Hangs Out With Surgeons |… Read More
By July 19, 2024
Podcast: Making Telemedicine About Consumers, Not Providers 7/18/24
Are providers finally figuring out that making telemedicine about consumers is the best way to solve chronic business… Read More
By July 18, 2024